9 Costly Home Insurance Claim Mistakes to Avoid

At Home Insurance Alternatives, we’re committed to helping homeowners make smart, informed decisions about protecting their property. Filing a claim can be stressful—but it doesn’t have to be. Avoiding Home Insurance Claim Mistakes can mean the difference between a smooth payout and a denied or delayed claim.

9 Common Home Insurance Claim Mistakes That Could Cost You

Here’s what every homeowner needs to know before filing their next claim:

1. Not Fully Understanding Your Coverage

Before disaster strikes, take time to understand the ins and outs of your home insurance policy. Too many homeowners realize too late that their policy doesn’t cover the damage they assumed it would.

• Know your coverage limits and deductibles
• Understand exclusions (like floods or earthquakes)
• Clarify if you have actual cash value or replacement cost coverage

Pro tip: Schedule a yearly policy review to avoid costly Home Insurance Claim Mistakes down the road.

2. Delaying Your Claim

Acting fast after damage is key. Some homeowners wait days—or even weeks—to notify their insurer, risking claim denial for untimely reporting.

• Report damage immediately
• Take date-stamped photos before cleanup
• Keep records of your communications

Prompt action prevents small issues from becoming major Home Insurance Claim Mistakes.

3. Inadequate Documentation

We’ve seen many claims denied or reduced simply due to poor documentation. When disaster happens, your camera is one of your most powerful tools.

• Take clear, detailed photos and videos
• Save receipts for temporary repairs and living expenses
• Document before-and-after visuals where possible

Avoid one of the most common Home Insurance Claim Mistakes by preparing in advance with a home inventory.

4. Making Permanent Repairs Too Soon

It’s understandable to want to fix damage quickly. However, making permanent repairs before an adjuster inspects the damage can undermine your claim.

• Only make emergency temporary repairs
• Save receipts and take before/after photos
• Wait for approval before major repairs

This is one of those Home Insurance Claim Mistakes that homeowners regret most.

5. Not Communicating Clearly with Your Insurance Provider

Clear and consistent communication with your insurer protects your claim. Failing to log calls or emails can result in disputes.

• Keep a written log of conversations
• Confirm verbal agreements via email
• Record names, dates, and details

Good communication helps avoid misunderstandings and Home Insurance Claim Mistakes.

6. Accepting the First Settlement Offer Without Review

The first offer isn’t always the best. Don’t accept less than you deserve just to get it over with.

• Compare the offer with actual repair estimates
• Don’t be afraid to negotiate
• Consider hiring a public adjuster

If you accept a low offer too quickly, it could be one of your biggest Home Insurance Claim Mistakes.

7. Throwing Away Damaged Property Too Early

Don’t discard damaged items before your adjuster reviews them—they serve as crucial evidence.

• Keep all items until your claim is settled
• Take photos if disposal is necessary

This is a surprisingly common Home Insurance Claim Mistakes among frustrated homeowners.

8. Inflating or Misrepresenting Damages

Honesty is critical. Exaggerated claims can lead to denial—or worse.

• Stick to the facts
• Provide legitimate estimates and receipts
• Be transparent

This is not just a mistake—it’s a legal risk among serious Home Insurance Claim Mistakes.

9. Being Underinsured Without Realizing It

A frequent mistake: policies that don’t meet the 80% rule, reducing your payout.

• Ensure your home is insured for at least 80% of replacement value
• Consider riders for high-value items

A quick review now can prevent one of the costliest Home Insurance Claim Mistakes later.

---

Mistakes Homeowners Make When Filing

Task	Action
Understand Policy	Review limits, exclusions, and coverage types
Report Damage Insurance Claims Quickly	Notify insurer and document damage immediately
Document Thoroughly	Take photos, videos, and keep receipts
Delay Major Repairs	Until adjuster visit and claim approval
Communicate Clearly	Track all conversations and agreements
Review Settlements	Don’t rush into accepting offers
Keep Damaged Items	Until inspection and settlement
Be Honest	Stick to verified facts and evidence
Update Coverage	Ensure policy keeps up with home value

---

State-Specific Claim Disputes and Insurance System Challenges

While homeowners often bear the blame for denied or delayed claims, in many states the issue lies within the insurance system itself. Here are some examples of insurer-side claim issues that homeowners should be aware of:

• Texas – High Rate of Claims Closed Without Payment: In 2024, Texas saw nearly 47% of home insurance claims closed without any payout, often due to high wind/hail deductibles and tight internal scrutiny. These aren’t due to mistakes by homeowners but reflect increasingly restrictive insurer practices when submitting a homeowners insurance claim.
• Texas – Policy Complexity: Texas homeowners often face policies with complex “duties after loss” that insurers may enforce rigidly to deny payouts—despite valid claims.
• Florida – Shrinkage of Private Insurance Market: As more insurers exit the state, homeowners are pushed into high-cost, limited-coverage policies with Citizens Property Insurance, the state-backed option.
• Florida – Frequent Litigation & Delays: Florida’s litigation-heavy climate leads to significant delays in payouts as insurers contest even clearly documented damages, especially post-hurricane.
• Mississippi – Wind vs. Flood Coverage Disputes: After major storms, homeowners in coastal Mississippi often find their claims denied based on how insurers classify the damage—wind damage vs. flood damage. Insurers have historically favored classifications that shift liability away from covered events.
• Washington – Claims Delayed Due to Adjuster Shortages: In wildfire-prone areas, especially in Eastern Washington, a shortage of qualified adjusters following disasters has led to extended wait times and delayed payments—even when documentation is complete.
• Nebraska –Denied Hail Claims Due to “Wear and Tear”: Insurers increasingly deny hail damage claims by citing “pre-existing wear,” even after recent storms. This tactic often limits valid payouts unless a second opinion or appeal is pursued.

Understanding the Insurance Claims Payment Process

Knowing how insurance companies pay out claims is just as crucial as avoiding mistakes when filing. According to the Insurance Information Institute, insurers often issue an initial payment based on the actual cash value (ACV) of the loss—this accounts for depreciation. Once repairs are completed and receipts are submitted, you may receive additional funds to cover the full replacement cost, provided your policy includes that coverage. This two-step process underscores the importance of maintaining good documentation and communicating consistently with your insurance provider. Understanding how payments are structured can help you avoid frustration and ensure you’re compensated fairly. Learn more here.

What Happens When an Insurance Company Makes a Mistake?

If an insurance company makes a mistake—such as miscalculating your payout, misclassifying damages, or delaying a valid claim—it can significantly impact your ability to recover. Homeowners have the right to request a correction, submit additional documentation, or escalate the issue through their insurer’s internal review process.

Need Help With High Risk Home Insurance?

Filing a claim doesn’t have to be painful. At Home Insurance Alternatives, we empower you to avoid Home Insurance Claim Mistakes through preparation, honesty, and informed action. Whether you’re reviewing your policy or navigating a current claim, we’re here to help you protect your home and your peace of mind.

Need help finding the best high risk home insurance alternative? Fill out our short form to get a free quote today.