Colorado Fair Plan and Options For High Risk Homes
Explore private home insurance alternatives to the Colorado FAIR Plan. Get comprehensive coverage for weather, water, wildfires, and floods.
Explore private home insurance alternatives to the Colorado FAIR Plan. Get comprehensive coverage for weather, water, wildfires, and floods.

From the mountain towns of Aspen and Telluride to the urban energy of Denver, Aurora, and Colorado Springs, Colorado is an incredible place to own a home. But for some residents, getting or keeping homeowners insurance can be a challenge.
Wildfire exposure, aging roofs, or a history of claims can make it difficult to secure coverage from some standard insurers. If you’ve been dropped from coverage or are having trouble finding insurance, you may have come across the Colorado FAIR Plan, officially known as the Colorado Property Insurance Plan.
This program exists to help eligible homeowners find coverage when it’s not available through the voluntary market. We connect Colorado homeowners with agents who specialize in high-risk properties throughout Colorado. These agents often have access to private carriers that may offer broader or more customized solutions depending on your situation.
The Colorado Property Insurance Plan is the most recent new FAIR (Fair Access to Insurance Requirements) Plan. These state plans were established to ensure access to basic property insurance for homeowners who may not be able to find it in the standard market.
Eligibility requirements and coverages can vary, but in general, homeowners must first attempt to obtain insurance from the voluntary market. The Colorado FAIR Plan helps make sure that insurance remains available to qualifying homeowners across the state.
Coverage Scope FAIR Plan policies generally focus on providing essential property coverage. Some protections commonly found in broader homeowners policies, such as liability, theft, water damage, or additional living expenses, may not be included or may be limited depending on the plan and any available endorsements.
Valuation Methods Some FAIR Plan policies may settle claims on an actual cash value basis, which accounts for depreciation when determining payouts. This can result in lower reimbursements compared to replacement cost coverage, which may be available through other markets.
Premium Considerations Premium levels for FAIR Plan policies can vary based on the property’s location, condition, and other underwriting factors. In some cases, coverage through the private market may offer a broader range of protections at comparable or better rates.

For some homeowners, it can be. Several factors influence the availability of insurance across the state:
Wildfire Risk: Areas with a history of wildfires or located near forests and wildland-urban interfaces may present additional underwriting challenges.
Older Homes and Roofs: Homes with aging systems, particularly roofs or electrical wiring, may require updates to qualify for standard coverage.
Claims History: A pattern of prior claims can impact eligibility, even if those claims are weather-related.
Market Conditions: Like other states, Colorado has experienced shifts in underwriting guidelines and market participation that affect availability in certain regions.
Colorado continues to maintain a strong and well-regulated insurance market, and many insurers actively write policies in the state. It’s often a matter of working with an agent who understands where to look for information.
If you’ve received a policy nonrenewal or are facing difficulty obtaining coverage, we can help. Our service connects you with agents who:
Specialize in helping homeowners in higher-risk categories, including those affected by wildfires, older homes, or multiple claims. Have access to a broader set of private insurers and surplus lines carriers that may not be available through traditional channels. Offer options that may include expanded protection and more flexibility.
Whether your property is in:
Wildfire-prone areas such as Evergreen, Nederland, or Manitou Springs; Larger urban centers like Denver, Aurora, or Colorado Springs; Or smaller communities with fewer insurance options…
We’ll help you compare solutions and explore whether private market alternatives are available and appropriate for your needs.
The Colorado FAIR Plan plays an important role in maintaining access to property insurance. While it can be a useful solution, many homeowners may also qualify for coverage through other avenues. If you’re unsure where to start, our team can help you find a knowledgeable agent to evaluate your situation and review your options.

The Colorado Property Insurance Plan is part of the national FAIR Plan pool of sorts. It provides access to basic property insurance for homeowners who cannot secure coverage through traditional channels.
Not necessarily. Many homeowners are eligible for private market policies that offer additional flexibility. We help connect you with agents who can assess those opportunities.
It depends on the situation. While some FAIR Plan premiums may be higher relative to their scope of coverage, others may be comparable. A licensed agent can help you compare options across the available market.
The Colorado FAIR Plan is funded by premiums paid by its policyholders. If the premiums and reserves are not enough to cover losses and expenses, the plan can levy assessments on all licensed property and casualty insurance companies that operate in the state.